Union carbide corporations ucc response to the curative petition filed by the union of india the union of india uois curative petition seeks to invalidate the final settlement of all claims arising out of the bhopal disaster, which was approved twice over by the supreme court of india over two decades ago. How bankruptcy affects real estate titles and bankruptcy. Pfi files curative petition in supreme court over ayodhya. These documents shined attention on the importance of eating certain. Fourth convict in nirbhaya gangrape case pawan gupta has filed a curative petition before supreme court of india. The handbook also states clearly that there is no limit within which a curative petition must be filed. The present curative petition is being filed against order dated. Pfi files curative petition in sc challenging ayodhya. The curative petitions are filed under article 142 of the constitution. Curative petition did not address the legal merits of the petition, but simply gave the parties notice that the petition had been filed and invited the parties to file.
It is the last judicial resort available for redressal of grievances in court which is normally decided by judges inchamber. Death row convict pawan gupta files curative petition in sc gupta, against whom the death warrant has been issued for execution along with three others, has filed the plea saying that the death penalty should not awarded to him. Honourable prime minister, government of india, north block, raisina hill, new delhi 110 011 august 1, 2014 sub. In our opinion, no case is made out within the parameters indicated. Meanwhile, nirbhaya convict akshay singhs wife files divorce petition in aurangabad court. The four convicts mukesh 31, pawan gupta 24, vinay sharma 25 and akshay kumar singh 33 in the december 2012 gangrape case.
After a delhi court issued the death warrant against all four convicts in 2012 nirbhaya delhi gangrape case, their lawyer ap singh on tuesday said that he will file a curative petition in supreme court seeking a stay on the same. File hours after one of the four death row convicts in the december 16 delhi gangrape case filed a curative petition before the supreme court, another convict mukesh filed the petition thursday evening. A certificate of the advocateonrecord to the effect that it is the first curative petition in the impugned matter. Centre to file curative petition in apex court india news. Five seniormost judges of the supreme court will hear it.
It is against the natural justice for not giving the reasons. In this scenario, the counsel of the convicts is left with only one option to file a curative petition in the top court. Supreme court rejects curative petitions filed over. No 3453472010 for additional compensation before supreme court on august 5, 2014. The concept of curative petition was evolved by the supreme court of india in the matter of rupa ashok hurra vs. Nirbhaya rape convict pawan gupta files mercy plea after. In addition to the us litigation, a criminal lawsuit against union carbide and warren anderson, its former ceo, has been ongoing in the indian legal system since 1989. The concept of curative petition was first evolved by the supreme court of india in the matter of rupa ashok hurra vs. It is meant to ensure there is no miscarriage of justice, and to prevent abuse of process. Sc dismisses curative petition filed by nirbhaya convict. While we do not yet have a description of the petition file format and what it is normally used for, we do know which programs are known to open these files. Curative filed its chapter 11 petition as a prepackaged plan, meaning that the reorganization plan is filed at the same time as the initial. Mar 17, 20 the concept of curative petition was evolved by the supreme court of india in the matter of rupa ashok hurra vs. No time limit is given for filing curative petition.
Fourth convict pawan gupta files curative petition in supreme court. Nirbhaya convict files curative petition, says he was only 19 years then. It is only in rare cases that such petitions are given an opencourt hearing. Curative petition in supreme court grounds for filing. With his curative petition dismissed, pawan can now file a mercy plea before president ram nath kovind. The curative petition is fairly a new concept in the indian legal system. What is a curative petition and what is the significance of the india supreme courts order responding to it. Organisation who and the diagnostic and statistical manual. January 9, 2020 by anushika srivastava akshay thakur singh, mukesh, pawan gupta, and vinay sharma were found guilty in 2012 gangrape, torture and killing of a young paramedic student in delhi.
An application for permission to file extended synopsis and list of. In accordance to the constitution of india, the supreme court is the protector of the constitution and the highest court of appeal. Singh, representing convict akshay kumar, said he has filed a curative plea and the apex court registry has sought some more documents along with the petition. Every day thousands of users submit information to us about which programs they use to open specific types of files. When the scientific report from the 2015 dietary guidelines advisory committee dgac was released early this year, it reiterated an important shift in u. However, filing a fresh contempt case would, certainly, give you an advantage over the opposition. He has requested the supreme court to commute his death sentence to. Pawan gupta is the fourth convict in nirbhaya rape case in row to file a curative petition in the apex court. What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link page.
In this article, mahima wahi discusses how to file a curative petition. The notice of hearing shall contain the following information. Similar pleas filed by akshay thakur, mukesh singh and vinay sharma were heard and dismissed by a fivejudge bench of the supreme court. It is guaranteed under article 7 of constitution of india i. The supreme court of india held in a 2002 case that it may reconsider its judgements exercising its inherent powers.
Honourable prime minister, government of india, new delhi 110 011. How to file curative petition in supreme court under order xlviii of supreme court rules 20 as per rupa ashok hurra v. We have gone through the curative petitions and the relevant documents. Another convict in the 2012 nirbhaya gangrape case, akshay thakur challenged his execution using the curative petition, the last available legal resort in the supreme court days before his scheduled hanging on february 1. A curative petition is filed after the plea conviction against final conviction is dismissed. Curative petition in supreme court conditions, who can. It is the last legal resort and a fairly new concept accessible for prevention of any abuse of. A curative petition is usually decided by judges in chamber, unless a specific request for an opencourt hearing is allowed. Will file curative petition in supreme court, says.
In its petition, the pfi has said that even though its not even a party to the main case, its interest was affected by the decision of the apex court. Nirbhaya convict files curative petition in supreme court days before hanging after a court issued death warrant against the four convicts in the nirbhaya case, convict vinay sharma has filed a curative petition in the supreme court. Pawan, 25, was the last death row convict in the case to have moved the sc with his curative plea, the final legal remedy available to a person. The supreme court on thursday dismissed the curative petition filed by an association of the victims of the 1997 uphaar cinema fire tragedy case, sparing the ansal brothers further jail term. Once ownership is established, an attorney often memorializes title informationread more. Sep 18, 2016 the supreme court on tuesday referred a batch of curative petitions against section 377 of the indian penal code, a colonialera provision criminalising consensual sexual acts of lesbian, gay. The petition files current curative petition to challenge the sentence imposed upon him, and raise relevant issues which have rendered the death penalty in the instant case as useless and regressive. Delhi gangrape case convict files curative petition in supreme court, days before hanging a delhi court had on january 7 issued a death warrant against four convicts in the 2012. A curative petition is a procedural device in indias legal system designed for use in rare and narrowly defined situations to correct judgments entered as a result of procedural judicial. Apr, 2020 nirbhaya case convicts may soon file curative petition against death penalty, court told 02 mar, 2019, 01.
A party shall convert the text and scanned documents into pdfa file and. Curative petition is the last judicial resort available for redressal of grievances in court which is normally decided by judges inchamber. Curative petition is the last to last resort in the line of due justice being given and the last opportunity of the unheard being heard. In the meeting, the committee members also decided to file a petition seeking the debris from the babri mosque to be handed over to them.
In june 2010 a court in india handed down a verdict in the case. There has been media, public and political pressure since the. The curative petition is filed along with a certificate from a senior designated advocate and can be file only on the grounds as mentioned in t. What are the conditions to file curative petition and certificate from senior advocate and advocate on record. In essence, the court concluded that the third district court of appeals decisionthat the statement was harmless in light of the curative instruction and other evidencewas not so unreasonableas to warrant habeas relief.
This year, the four convicts filed a mercy petition which was rejected by the president of india. Fivejudge constitution bench to take a call on section 377. Jan 11, 2017 this and the fact that there is an existing contempt case against the lic should not go unnoticed by the court while hearing the curative petition. The popular front of india pfi on friday filed a curative petition in the supreme court over the ayodhya land case verdict. Can a curative petition keep the nirbhaya convicts from. The writ petitioner naz foundation files wp c 74552001 before the high. Since april 2002 when the supreme court propounded the modalities of curative petitions, five hundred and sixty eight curative petitions have been filed before the supreme court. One of the convicts in the nirbhaya rape case, vinay kumar sharma, filed a curative petition before the supreme court on.
As the noose tightened around the convicts in the nirbhaya case, 2 out of the 4 facing death sentence, vinay sharma and mukesh singh in the nirbhaya rape case, decided to file curative. Read more about nirbhaya rape convicts lawyer to file curative petition by soon on business standard. A curative petition is a post decision exercise with very limited width at the admission level itself. As far as possible no open court hearings are conducted. The centre is planning to file a curative petition in the supreme court sc against its order to commute to life term the death penalty of 15 convicts on grounds of delay in disposal of their mercy petitions by the president. In accordance to the constitution of india, the supreme. The mercy petitions of the three other convicts have already been dismissed. Delhi gang rape convict pawan gupta files curative plea in. The supreme court on monday dismissed a curative petition filed by convict pawan kumar gupta who was sentenced to death in the 2012 nirbhaya gang rape and murder case. We will file a curative petition in the supreme court within two days. The babri masjid action committee bmac on wednesday held a meeting to mull over filing a curative petition against the supreme courts verdict in the ayodhya title dispute case. A curative petition, in simple words, is the final and last option for the people to acquire justice as mentioned and promised by the constitution of india. The curative petition is then circulated to the three senior most judges and the judges who delivered the impugned judgement, if available. It can be entertained if the petitioner establishes that there was a violation of the principles of natural justice, and that he was not heard by the court before passing an order.
Nirbhaya convict pawan gupta files curative petition in. As the curative petition is the last chance for justice and rarity and there are so many stipulations in filing the curative petition. Title curative is a set of procedures used to cure defects in chains of title, such as correcting instruments that are erroneous or ambiguous. The petitioner without any facts on record cannot file the petition. Supreme courts sixjudge bench to hear today the curative petition. Convict files curative petition in supreme court days before hanging. The concept of curative petition was evolved by the supreme court of india in the matter of. Government of india goi files curative petition in 2010, after the verdict in the criminal case, a group of ministers was formed to consider additional compensation to victims of the disaster and other measures. A curative petition is the final and last option for the people to acquire justice as mentioned and promised by the constitution of india. Nirbhaya convict files curative petition, says he was only. Four days before their scheduled date of hanging, pawan kumar gupta, a convict in the gangrape and murder of a 23yearold medical student in delhi dubbed nirbhaya by the media today filed a. Subsequently, in december 2010, the goi filed a curative petition in the supreme court seeking.
Curative petition inherent jurisdiction of the supreme. The decorated concept is a must as judges are human beings and to err is human. Thakur became the third convict to file a curative petition in the case, using it as the last legal resort. This article was first published on january 8, 2020 and republished on january 9, 2020, after one of the convicts in the nirbhaya case filed a curative petition in the supreme court against. The last chance after last chance curative jurisprudence. Pdf files videos latest videos of pdf files times of india. Delhi gang rape convict pawan gupta files curative plea in sc against death sentence pawan gupta is the only one among the four convicts to have not exhausted all their legal remedies. In our opinion, no case is made out within the parameters indicated in the decision of this court in rupa ashok hurra vs. What are the conditions under order xlviii of supreme court rules 2012. The popular front of india has filed a curative petition in the supreme court challenging the verdict in the ayodhya case. What can you do if a supreme court order or judgement is. Curative petitions are such petitions that have seen a comparatively newer introduction in the field of law in our country. Pdf files check out for the latest videos of pdf files at times of india.
Nirbhaya rape convicts lawyer to file curative petition by. Vazquez then appealed the denial of his 2254 petition to. The present curative petition is being filed against order dated 28. The instant application supports the curative petition against the impugned judgment of this honble court in cr. Counsel for the convicts filed a curative petition in the supreme court which was rejected by the court and accordingly mercy petition was filed which was also dismissed. Such petitions serve as the final and last option for the parties to get justice as promised and guaranteed to each one of us through the constitution of india. One of the four death row convicts in the nirbhaya gangrape and murder case approached the supreme court on wednesday with a curative petition.
549 705 948 127 450 875 695 475 1253 426 621 112 1108 1290 158 836 1487 469 1166 884 301 313 1242 1336 368 327 233 227 932 861